Awkward Achievements
So, I finally got my account back yesterday. I didn't think it would be so soon, or I would've held off on Arkham City another couple of days. Regardless, all of the achievements I earned while playing offline since I've been home were overwritten, but I still have access to my save files - I wasn't sure how this would pan out, if my save files would be accessible from my recovered gamertag despite being started by its now nonexistent offline counterpart.

I started New Game+ in Arkham City yesterday, having gotten my gamertag back and being able to download the Catwoman content. Awesomely enough, the story achievements popped in New Game+, so those are mostly in order, bu...

Awkward Achievements
So, I finally got my account back yesterday. I didn't think it would be so soon, or I would've held off on Arkham City another couple of days. Regardless, all of the achievements I earned while playing offline since I've been home were overwritten, but I still have access to my save files - I wasn't sure how this would pan out, if my save files would be accessible from my recovered gamertag despite being started by its now nonexistent offline counterpart.

I started New Game+ in Arkham City yesterday, having gotten my gamertag back and being able to download the Catwoman content. Awesomely enough, the story achievements popped in New Game+, so those are mostly in order, but prior to starting the new game, I played through the Catwoman episodes on their own, so my first achievement in Arkham City is Arkham City Sirens from about halfway through the game. And despite the story achievements popping for New Game+ throughout, at the end, I was not accredited the normal game completion achievement, just Twice Nightly, the New Game+ one. I also rescued the 3rd Riddler hostage before my achievements credit me with the first two.

In AC:Rev, I did literally all of the single player achievements excepting Sage, which I'm just saving gold up to complete. So in all likelihood, Sage will be the first achievement I unlock in Revelations, which'll be hilarious.

tl;dr, my Assassin's Creed and Arkham City achievements will be in an order that makes no sense.